मुख्य सामग्री पर जाएं
Chapter 5 Verse 4
5.4
सांख्ययोगौ पृथग्बालाः प्रवदन्ति न पण्डिताः | एकमप्यास्थितः सम्यगुभयोर्विन्दते फलम् ||४||

Saankhya-yogau prthag baalaah pravadanti na panditaah | Ekam apy aasthitah samyag ubhayor vindate phalam ||4||

अनुवाद

Only the childish say that Sankhya and yoga are different — not the learned. One who is perfectly established in even one of them obtains the fruits of both.

शब्दार्थ

सांख्य

Sankhya/analytical path of knowledge

योगौ

and yoga/devotional action

पृथक्

as separate/different

बालाः

the childish/ignorant

प्रवदन्ति

declare/say

not

पण्डिताः

the learned/wise

एकम्

one of them

अपि

even

आस्थितः

being established in

सम्यक्

properly/perfectly

उभयोः

of both

विन्दते

obtains/enjoys

फलम्

the fruit/result

टीका

Commentary

This verse delivers one of the Gita’s most integrating teachings. Krishna says that the idea of Sankhya and yoga being fundamentally different paths is held by the baalaah — a word that literally means children, but here means those who have not yet developed spiritual discrimination. The panditah, the truly learned, see no such separation.

What is Sankhya here? In the Gita’s usage, Sankhya refers to the path of discriminative inquiry — the analytical investigation of what is real, what is the self, what is matter, what is the Divine. It is the path of jnana, knowledge. Yoga here refers to the path of devoted, unattached action — karma yoga, the path of engaged service.

The apparent difference between these paths is real at the surface level. The Sankhya practitioner sits, investigates, withdraws from activity to examine the nature of reality. The karma yogi engages fully with the world, acting without clinging to outcomes. These look different. But at the level of what they ultimately accomplish — the dissolution of ego-identification and the recognition of one’s true nature — they arrive at exactly the same place.

Ekam api aasthitah — established perfectly in even one of them. The word samyak (perfectly, properly) is the key. Half-hearted practice of either path leads nowhere. But genuine, deep, committed practice of either leads to the complete fruit: liberation, full realization. This is an important acknowledgment: a person does not need to pursue both paths simultaneously. Wholehearted commitment to one is sufficient.

Historical Context

The rivalry between Sankhya philosophy (associated with the sage Kapila) and the various schools of yoga was a live intellectual debate in ancient India. The Gita’s position — that they are ultimately one in their destination — was a philosophical reconciliation that influenced Indian thought for centuries. Shankaracharya, Ramanuja, and Madhva all engaged with this verse in their commentaries, each reading the unity in terms of their own philosophical systems.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Bhagavad Gita 5.4 mean?
Only the childish say that Sankhya and yoga are different — not the learned. One who is perfectly established in even one of them obtains the fruits of both.
What is the Sanskrit text of Bhagavad Gita 5.4?
The original Sanskrit verse is: Saankhya-yogau prthag baalaah pravadanti na panditaah | Ekam apy aasthitah samyag ubhayor vindate phalam ||4||
What are the key themes of this verse?
This verse explores: sankhya, yoga, unity-of-paths, wisdom, discrimination, knowledge.
sankhyayogaunity-of-pathswisdomdiscriminationknowledge

यह श्लोक शेयर करें